Can a machine originate an idea that its maker did not supply?
Span 1770–1950
Works 8
Languages French, English
Status Draft question and agent-proposed arguments. Source checks are partial; historian review is pending.
7 answers are hidden while the authors build this question’s position key.
Sometimes in dreaming, he has memory, then he retraces to himself the objects which have struck him faithfully;--at other times, these modifications renew themselves without order, and without connection, very differently from those, which real objects have before excited in his interior organ. If in a dream he believes he sees a friend, his brain renews in itself the modifications or the ideas which this friend had formerly excited--in the same order that they arranged themselves when his eyes really beheld him--this is nothing more than an effect of memory. If in his dream he fancies he sees a monster which has no model in nature, his brain is then modified in the same manner that it was by the particular, by the detached ideas, with which it then does nothing more than compose an ideal whole; by assembling, and associating, in a ridiculous manner, the scattered ideas that were consigned to its keeping; it is then, that in dreaming he has imagination.Retained as a reserve/context passage for the original question; no stronger alternative placement established.